Will filing a storm damage claim increase my insurance rates?

  1. Home
  2. Blog
  3. Oct 2024

When it comes to insurance, there are a number of factors that can influence your premium. One of the more misunderstood aspects involves "Acts of God," such as natural disasters and catastrophic events. While these types of incidents might not directly affect your individual premium, the widespread nature of such events and the claims submitted by others can have an impact on insurance rates as a whole. This article will explore the dynamics of insurance claims following natural disasters, how they influence premiums, and what to expect when an “Act of God” occurs.

What Is an Act of God in Insurance?

An "Act of God" refers to an event that is caused by natural forces outside of human control. Common examples include:

Earthquakes
Hurricanes
Floods
Tornadoes
Wildfires
Hailstorms

These events are generally unpredictable and can cause significant damage to property and infrastructure. Most homeowners' and auto insurance policies cover damage caused by these events, provided that policyholders have the correct coverage in place. However, even though the insured party may have no control over such disasters, the consequences can affect their insurance rates in unexpected ways.

How Does Filing a Claim Work for Acts of God?

If your home or car is damaged in an event categorized as an Act of God, your insurance policy will typically allow you to file a claim to recover the costs of repairs or replacements. For example, if a hurricane causes damage to your roof or a tree falls on your car during a storm, you can file a claim to cover the damages.

The key thing to remember is that filing a claim for an Act of God will not typically result in a premium increase directly tied to that claim. This is largely because the event is beyond your control, and insurers usually understand that. However, the dynamics of insurance rates are more complex than just your individual claims history. Even if your specific claim does not raise your rate, other factors associated with a major natural disaster could still affect the overall cost of insurance.

The Ripple Effect: Increased Rates After a Catastrophic Event

Even if you don’t submit a claim or if your property isn't affected by a large catastrophic event, your insurance premiums may still increase. Here's why:

Mass Claims Submissions: After an Act of God, particularly a large-scale event like a hurricane or wildfire, insurance companies are inundated with claims. The financial toll on insurers can be significant. To compensate for the substantial losses incurred from processing and paying out large numbers of claims, insurance companies may raise rates for everyone in the affected area or across the entire customer base.

Reinsurance Costs: Insurance companies themselves purchase insurance, known as reinsurance, to protect against large-scale claims. After a natural disaster, the cost of reinsurance can increase dramatically. These rising costs are often passed down to policyholders in the form of higher premiums.

Risk Reassessment: After a catastrophic event, insurance companies may reassess the risks associated with certain geographic areas. A region that was previously deemed low-risk for hurricanes, for example, may suddenly be viewed as more vulnerable following a major storm. This reassessment can lead to higher premiums for people living in that area, even if they never submitted a claim themselves.

Market-Wide Adjustments: Sometimes, the sheer scale of a disaster forces insurers to adjust their rates market-wide. If a particular type of disaster becomes more frequent or more severe due to climate change or other factors, insurers may increase premiums across the board to mitigate future risks. For example, regions historically free from significant wildfire risk may see higher premiums as insurers anticipate greater exposure.

Why Your Premium Might Go Up, Even Without a Claim

It’s important to understand that insurance premiums are not only affected by your personal claims history. When a large number of people in your area submit claims after an Act of God, the collective financial burden on the insurance company can lead to a rise in premiums for everyone in the region.

Consider the following hypothetical scenario:

A hurricane causes widespread damage across a coastal region. Even though your home is spared, many of your neighbors file claims for roof damage, water damage, or destroyed personal property.

It’s important to understand that insurance premiums are not only affected by your personal claims history. When a large number of people in your area submit claims after an Act of God, the collective financial burden on the insurance company can lead to a rise in premiums for everyone in the region.



The insurance company processes a massive number of claims, paying out millions or even billions of dollars in total damages.

To recover from the losses and to hedge against future risks, the insurance company raises premiums across the region. Even though you didn’t submit a claim, your premium rises because of the overall increased risk in your area.

Acts of God are unpredictable, and while insurance exists to help recover from the damage they cause, these events can also have unexpected financial consequences, even for those who don’t file claims. Understanding the interplay between natural disasters, insurance claims, and premium increases is essential for navigating the often-complicated world of insurance.

While your individual claim may not cause your premium to rise, widespread claims and higher risks following a disaster can affect your rates. By staying informed and proactive, you can mitigate the financial impact and ensure you have the coverage you need at a price that works for you.

If you have any questions or need assistance with your insurance claims, don't hesitate to contact us. We're here to ensure you have the information and support you need to protect your home and assets effectively.

Disclaimer